Inside: 11 of the Best Mystery Games that will bring out your inner detective. 

There’s no denying that murder mysteries have become something of an obsession for many in recent years. But this isn’t exactly a new trend. When you think about it, mystery movies, shows, and games have been around for decades.

If you’re looking to dive into a game that will help you flex your detective skills, then check out our compilation of the best mystery games that you can play alone, in groups, and over and over again.

The best mystery games are re-playable, immersive, and challenging enough that you don’t fly through the game without much effort.

After all, you want to be a part of the experience and be the one to crack the case!

Mystery games for parties

Take a look at the 11 best mystery games that will make you feel like a modern day Sherlock Holmes.

The Best Detective Games For Mystery Enthusiasts

If you’re looking for a challenge, then look no further! Check out some of the best mystery games that will have you sorting through clues and challenging your deductive reasoning to deliver justice.

Keep in mind that some of these games are not well suited for younger players.

Crime scene party games

  1. Unsolved Case Files:  Unsolved Case Files is a series of Cold Case Murder Mystery activities. Each game has a different crime that needs to be solved. In each version, you must find the necessary clues among over 50 investigation documents and photos. Check in with the online guide to progress forward and prove that you’ve solved the mystery! Some game sets include the cases of Harmony Ashcroft and Jamie Banks. These are the best detective activities for those who really want to get down to the level of the detectives and investigators in realistic cases! 
  2. Murder Mystery Party Case Files:  The Murder Mystery Party Case Files are among the best mystery games out there! This is another series with multiple cases and scenarios to solve. Can you prove the innocence of your client and identify the real killer? Check out the Fire in Alderstein game pack for a look at gameplay!
  3. Hunt A Killer Game Series:  The Hunt A Killer packs are a series of immersive experiences with varying difficulty. Play solo or in groups to crack the case! Game sets include Body On The Boardwalk and Death At The Dive Bar. Best for teenagers and older players, you’ll need to sort through all of the clues and evidence to uncover secrets and deceit. There is also an online guide to both confirm your deductions and help guide you if things get too challenging.
  4. Mystery At Magnolia Gardens:  Help Nancy Drew solve the case! In this game, players must sort through the evidence, create a timeline of the crime, and sort fact from fiction. This exciting game is easy to learn, play, and complete in one sitting. Perfect for families and party nights! This game is best for players aged 14 and older, and takes between an hour and 90 minutes to play. 
  5. There’s Been A Murder:  This fun card game is great for groups small and large and is different each time you play. Each card has different effects and perks, meaning that you have to strategize with your teammates to catch the culprit! The only catch is: one of the players is the killer! Tread carefully and trust wisely.

Exciting Adventure Mystery Games For Game Night

Adventure mystery games

One of the biggest appeals of the best mystery games out there is the immersion. You want to follow the journey of a real detective to solve the case and bring down the criminal and feel like you’re there at the crime scene while you play.

Here are some of the best mystery games that take you on an adventure while you play!

  1. Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective:  Wander the streets of London, meet helpful hands and frightful foes, and solve mysteries as you channel your inner Sherlock Holmes! This game is intense and intriguing and recommended for ages 12 and older. It comes with a plethora of cases to solve and is challenging enough to keep the fun going! 
  2. Hidden Games Crime Scene – The Midnight Crown:  This is the case of a simple burglary. Or is it? Uncover the secrets of the Midnight Crown in London, working with the other players in your group to investigate an intriguing murder mystery. This game is also smartphone friendly, so you may even get the teenagers in your family to play along!
  3. Ravensburger Echoes:  Ravensburger Echoes: The Cocktail is an audio-based mystery game that will engage all of your senses. This game comes with an app for you to use as you play along. Scan your evidence cards and unlock clues to expose evil plots and bring the criminals to justice!
  4. Murder Mystery At The Ugly Sweater Office Holiday Party:  The name is a bit of a mouthful, but it’s super fun and you can even play virtually! You can also play with up to 20 people, making it perfect for an actual office party, family reunion, or any other gathering large or small. Different roles each time makes for endless replayability. Who’s the killer? It’s up to you to find out! 
  5. Murder Mystery On The Night Train:  Host a classic murder mystery dinner party with this game set. With all of the game cards, introductions, and details sorted out for you, all you need to do is gather your friends and start playing! This game is gorgeously designed and comes with so many different scenarios and combinations that you’ll have no trouble playing again and again without getting bored.
  6. Mystery Tonic: One Minute Mysteries:  Are you looking for a quick game to fill quiet moments or kill time before dinner? Like, really quick? Then this game is for you! This card pack comes with 80 cards and instructions. With the case information and clues provided to you, can you solve the case? It’s so portable, easy to learn, and easy to play that your friends are going to want you to bring this one along to every gathering!

More Fun Game Ideas You’ll Love

  • 40 Hilarious Bachelor Games – A wedding is the best day of your life… with a whole bunch of exciting days and awesome events leading right up to it! And one of those exciting events is the groom’s bachelor party. To plan an evening that’s as memorable as all of the rest, check out these hilarious bachelor party activities! You’ll have a blast with your closest friends and give everyone a night to remember.
  • 25+ Hilarious Cocktail Party Games – Let me begin by saying that it’s important to always drink and play responsibly. That being said, don’t be afraid to let loose and have a great time with some awesome cocktail party games! Learn more about your friends and even yourself with these hilarious and thought-provoking activities. The laughter will roll all evening long!
  • 17 Sweet Candy Games For Parties – Got a child with a sweet tooth? Then you can’t miss this collection of our favorite candy-based games! These activities won’t just give your kid a sugar rush: they’ll help them develop their creativity, fine motor, and reasoning skills. And candy is the perfect incentive to get them to play along! These activities are kind of the perfect mom hack, really.